Dec 02, 2012 harry potter plot holes lately, i have been rereading the harry potter books, as any good potterhead does at least once a year. We went ahead and rounded them all up for you, and we honestly cant stop laughing. Harry potter adaptation induced plot hole tv tropes. Mistakes in the harry potter books harry potter wiki fandom. While we are on the subject of harry s terrible loss, theres a second plot hole related to his memories of his past. However, he should have been able to see the thestrals after professor quirrell died from harrys touch in philosophers stone. Despite how much i like the harry potter series, it is undeniable that it contains quite a few inconsistencies throughout, with varying degrees of impact to the overall story. That may sound all fine and dandy, but some of the readers dislike certain elements in the book series. Dec 01, 2017 9 harry potter plot holes that still keep us up at night. Six plot holes in the harry potter novels im sure you all love harry potter, but precisely because of this, you also know that the books are flawed. Voldemorts needlessly convoluted plan to get harry through the triwizard tournament that almost failed dozens of times, instead of simply giving him a port key at the start.
Nov 25, 2016 we love harry potter, but weve got questions. Its hard to believe that its now been over ten years since the final novel in the harry potter series was released. Dumbledore left once the da was exposed and hagrid fled the grounds following an. Rowling that she was able to create an entirely new monetary system but perhaps math wasnt her strong point, because when it comes to wizarding currency, the numbers dont always add up. The biggest holes in the plot of harry potter 22 words. Browse other questions tagged harrypotter or ask your own question.
Aug 09, 2017 so what are the biggest plot holes in the potterverse. Harry can now see the thestral creatures because he witnessed cedric diggorys death in goblet of fire. All the mistakes, plot holes in harry potter books and movies. No one is disputing that harry potter is one of the best book and movie franchises of all time. In harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban, i am confused about the whole ending. Some of these mistakes were fixed in later editions of the same book. Hey, after not receiving your hogwarts letter when you turned 11, who could blame you. The story is honestly epic, but you may not have noticed that there are actually a ton of plot holes in the series. Dec 12, 2001 as the book explains, it turns out that the schools kindly headmaster, albus dumbledore, gave harry the cloak. Apr 05, 2016 yes, there are even plot holes in harry potter. Here are 15 things about harry potter that make no sense. You can list minor ones if you like, but if anyone has any major conflicting plot holes, they are welcome to.
It is possible, however, that the illustration is of. With the release of harry potter and the cursed child, many potterheads were excited to jump back into the wizarding world. Plot holes in harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban. Why wouldnt professors snape and lupin the werewolf tell the ministry the whole story, since they were both t. What are the biggest plot holes and errors in harry potter. From plottoplot, book to book, many of her motives are. As the book explains, it turns out that the schools kindly headmaster, albus dumbledore, gave harry the cloak. Please list plot holes from any book in the harry potter series. But like the movie, rowling doesnt say what happens to it after harry drops it.
And harry potter fans who know the wizarding world inside and out cant help but notice a few things that just dont make sense. Some of these mistakes were fixed in later editions of the same. It seems they love to look at unregulated violence in their game as if it was part of the deal which makes. Harry potter books plot holes image collections book. In the book, harry had to resort to saving sirius himself because umbridges actions had coincidentally driven every member of the order but snape away from the school, meaning he couldnt go to any of them for help. Jk rowlings fantasy series remains one of the most popular franchises ever conceived.
All the mistakes, plot holes in harry potter books and. In philosophers stone, harrys letter from hogwarts says he may bring a cat, an owl, or a. The twoway mirror that sirius gives to harry in the fifth book is left out of the film. Despite being the titular character, i have found that harry is not the favorite character of the majority of readers. We solemnly swear harry potter fans are up to no good when it comes to finding plot holes. Its beautifully crafted, charming, engaging, and generally just the best thing to come to childrens fantasy books in a long, long time.
I reacted to harry potter plot holes and discussed them. May 11, 2020 tiny plot holes that distracted people harry potter 10 plotholes from the chamber of secrets plot holes 7 major harry potter plot. Biggest plot holes in harry potter books image collections book. Rowling herself has admitted that the story has a few plot holes but while some of these. In fact, i hold the harry potter books and movies in very high esteem. The elder wand was supposed to be unbeatable, but dumbledore defeats grindlewald to win it. No one could recognize harry after hermione used the stinging curse on him to disguise him from the snatchers. For many, it was their first and final midnight release of the series. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 plot holes. As seen in the initial escape sequence, powerful wizards cannot differentiate the.
Harry potter and the chamber of secrets plot holes by. Six plot holes in the harry potter novels terry graves. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets plot holes by comptinator the crowd full of immensely powerful wizards does not lift a single wand to help him. Why harry never helped ron to buy a wand in the second book. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 plot holes bellatrix tries to resolve the matter by showing harrys deformed face to draco malfoy instead of actually using magic on him.
One of the most confusing bits about harry potter is how. Top 20 harry potter plot holes best, most, greatest of. Harry potter may be one of the most beloved series in the world, but that doesnt mean j. The real plot hole part of this is that if harry had just done this, they could have shown fudge the scene and proved that it had happened. Mistakes in the harry potter books harry potter wiki. Starting off with the first book, this a plot hole that most people are familiar with, but it is. When i first learned of thesterals as a reader in the fifth harry potter book, i thought this seemed like a major plot hole. Quirrell crumbles into dust dying while harry is still conscious, watching, and fully aware of what he is seeing, thus allowing it to fully sink. Feb 17, 2019 the story is honestly epic, but you may not have noticed that there are actually a ton of plot holes in the series.
I think that can be attributed the the plethora of great characters that j. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 plot holes bellatrix tries to resolve the matter by showing harry s deformed face to draco malfoy instead of actually using magic on him. No novel in the world could resist as close a scrutiny as this saga without several errors and plot holes being spotted. The plot hole that ate a mother and father theleaky. But their ultimate goal is to find out more about harrys past and defeat the dark lord known as voldemort. Theres no denying that harry potter is one of the most magical series ever written, but the story does have a few frustrating plot holes. Below is a list of mistakes that occur in the harry potter book series, such as plot holes and typos.
Then in the fifth book harry potter and the order of the phoenix, dumbledore quickly makes a portkey to transport harry and the weasley children to number 12 grimauld place. The biggest holes in the plot of harry potter 22 words when youre dealing with a madeup magical world, theres just gonna be some plot holes and harry potter has some pretty crazy ones. Harry potter has one huge plot hole you mightve missed. In the book of prisoner of azkaban, remus lupin explains to harry that he, sirius black, james potter and peter pettigrew created the marauders map, and that the nicknames moony, padfoot, prongs. Clearly, dumbledore already had the pensieve, because harry had used it to accidentally witness the three wizengamots trials while in dumbledores office.
While the plot hole is very plain and simple, the implications are whats interesting here for me. This time, however, i started to notice some things that just didnt add up. With timeturners, whenever something bad happens voldemort. Some of my favorite examples of dont even try to explain this plot holes are. Take a journey through the dangerous plot holes that threaten the credibility of these beloved characters. As seen in the initial escape sequence, powerful wizards cannot differentiate the real harry potter from decoys while hedwig can. So what are the biggest plot holes in the potterverse.
Oct 29, 2019 despite how much i like the harry potter series, it is undeniable that it contains quite a few inconsistencies throughout, with varying degrees of impact to the overall story. Hagrid simply disappearing in the first book, despite him not having learned to apparate. Index the wizengamot archive plot holes i think ive identified some plot holes in the harry potter series if theyve already been discussed it would great if a link could be provided, and i would like if we could discuss them and, in case they arent plot holes, to be told so and to be explained why not. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled scienceblogs. Not even ron with his 5 brothers going before him as well as his parents. Here are ten of the biggest continuity errors in the harry potter series. Because if that happened the goblet of fire would be a picture book that looks pathetic on your harry potter bookshelf. She often fumbles about in her books not seeming to know where she is going. Harry potter and the gaping plot holes quiz 10 questions. Harry potter and the numerous plotholes home facebook. All are present in the film series, but a startling amount come from the source material. Anything that means harry potter isnt really over should be music to the ears of diehard fans, but this most recent film the second in j. The third book had its own slew of plot twists werewolf lupin, the timeturner, harry saves himself from dementors, scabbers, but sirius black turning out.
Its beautifully crafted, charming, engaging, and generally just the best thing to come to childrens fantasy books in. There were many questions that remained unanswered, as well as several plot holes that seemed to be forgotten about. Not only is the wizarding world strange enough to have only developed one sport, the single sport that they have makes zero sense. Harry potter plot holes lately, i have been rereading the harry potter books, as any good potterhead does at least once a year. Harry potter and the cursed child is a 2016 british twopart play written by jack thorne based on an original story by j. Rowling that she was able to create an entirely new monetary system but perhaps math wasnt her strong point, because when it comes to. I love the harry potter series, and i dont mean any disrespect to jk rowling or the books themselves. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban i dont understand why dumbledore tolerated the way the dursleys treated harry so poorly. However, after reading through the script, many fans were upset with how many uncharacteristic plot holes there were. Harry potter will always be regarded as one of the best book and film. Read on for fifteen of the biggest plot holes in the series. A few glaring plot holes in harry potter must be addressed. T heres no denying that harry potter is one of the most magical series ever written, but even j.
Biggest plot holes in harry potter business insider. Scroll through our gallery to see all the mistakes and plot holes in the harry potter series. The harry potter series is quite the masterpiece, but no book is perfect. Cover the art for the cover of the original uk edition depicts harry at platform nine and threequarters wearing a gryffindor scarf, however, harry hasnt been sorted yet. Harry potter plot holes and questions explained time. Rewrite harry potter and well guess which book is your. This is the the biggest plot hole in harry potter indy100. Tiny plot holes that distracted people harry potter 10 plotholes from the chamber of secrets plot holes 7 major harry potter plot. Over the years, fans have put together a long list of discrepancies and theories from the books and movies. But in 2004, rowling answered this question in an interview at. Thank you for liking and subscribing whatre your thoughts on these plot holes. Harry potter might have ended, but they didnt tie up all the loose ends. No one is disputing that harry potter is one of the best book and movie franchises of all time, but that doesnt mean there arent flaws.
When these floating guardians of azkaban first appear on the hogwarts train, the majority of the children feel cold and miserable but harry can hear someone screaming, collapses, and needs professor lupin to drive the dementor away from him. Still, here are some of the mysteries and plot holes in the harry potter universe that are as yet unsolved. In the book, harry ended up smashing the mirror in frustration after a failed attempt to use it to contact sirius beyond the grave. Jan 04, 2016 the third book had its own slew of plot twists werewolf lupin, the timeturner, harry saves himself from dementors, scabbers, but sirius black turning out to be a good guy was the main reversal. This is a plot gap simply absent from story not a plot hole a istake surrounded by correct info. This creates some rather glaring continuity problems further down the line for the deathly hallows films.
Even if he didnt want harry to know that he was a wizardworld rock star, he might have had hagrid drop by one day when harry wasnt around to. I recently discovered that there is a widespread belief that there is a huge, gaping, plot hole in harry potter goblet of fire by j. Jan 17, 2020 i reacted to harry potter plot holes and discussed them. The fantastic world of harry potter is, without a doubt, absolutely incredible. Harry potter has one huge plot hole harry potter plot holes that were what this harry potter plot hole time travel in harry potter is not a plot holes page 12. Yet in the end of the last book, harry is openly discussing the event. Its not a plot hole, just sometimes fans need to give jkr some slack. Nov 20, 2017 t heres no denying that harry potter is one of the most magical series ever written, but even j.
1585 771 513 255 1321 930 1294 1405 534 242 28 1347 698 1173 680 340 848 1494 351 774 70 1234 119 361 1391 200 1509 602 27 126 731 832 1273 1518 511 1424 981 1009 787 183 123 555 1395